Astronomy Hawaii

Astronomical odds for grad student

Astronomy Hawaii UH

AstroDay2018 is a hit

Astronomy Hawaii Gemini

It is rocket science: Astronomy educators reaching out to Big Island students

Astronomy Hawaii TMT

TMT Supporters Rally as Final Arguments Are Filed in Contested Case

Supporters of the Thirty Meter Telescope project held a sign-waving rally in Hilo, Hawaii yesterday, May 30, which was the deadline for parties in the contested case hearing to submit their Findings of Fact.

The event appears to have been a fun-filled success with lots of Hawaii locals, including native Hawaiians, joining to show their support for the project. Representatives from the University of Hawaii Institute for Astronomy also attended the rally.

A sign-raving support rally for TMT takes place in Hilo, Hawaii. Image: Hawaii Tribune-HeraldAccording to the Hawaii Tribune-Herald – who actually gave the rally front-page coverage in the Wednesday paper – DLNR senior communications manager Dan Dennison said in an email that four written arguments had been filed as of early Tuesday afternoon, with three available for online viewing at press time. The filings were from the Temple of Lono, Deborah J. Ward (one of the original six parties in the first contested case, which was held in 2011) and Dwight Vicente. HTH noted that “the current case has 25 parties, but not all have participated in testimony to the same extent” and that “The written arguments submitted so far ranged in length from 93 pages to four pages.”

Comments on the Herald’s corresponding website post included sentiments like

The tallest mountain in the world can be shared, especially for something as noble intent as an astronomical telescope to expand human knowledge of the universe. It’s not called the Big Isand for nothing. That is true aloha.


In addition to the contribution to the furtherance of science the TMT will make, what has recently occurred to me is the kind of people the TMT will draw to the island. I have known two scientists who have come here specifically because of the existing telescopes. One is a brilliant woman from Germany who lives in the neighborhood, and one was a brilliant guy from Minnesota, who visited a neighbor (his aunt and uncle) for the opportunity to observe at one of the telescopes. Both are fine people who are a pleasure to have on the island. Any area would be lucky to have them, and it certainly can’t hurt us to raise the average on-island IQ by a few points with all of these scientists sharing our space (pun intended).

Thayne Currie, an astronomer working on Mauna Kea, added:

Yesterday was the filing deadline for proposed Findings of Fact/Conclusions of Law. The parties will have two weeks to respond to others’ findings and then the judge will make a ruling some time after that. The process is moving along.

TMT Protest Caltech May 30At the same time as the rally in Hilo, Hawaii, an underwhelming protest took place at Caltech in Pasadena, California (because of their involvement with the TMT project), that turned out the same small amount of people (somewhere between 6 – 10) as the previous one did about a month ago.

The previous couple of weeks has seen a few other important milestones for the case and Hawaii astronomy community.

It’s worth noting that the most recent poll conducted by Tulchin Research actually indicated an uptick in support for TMT compared to the last one, with more Hawaii residents and native Hawaiians being moved to raise their voices to combat the constant stream of lies and misleading statements put forth by the protesters.

TMT Support Hawaii's Future
TMT supporters at a sign-waving rally in Hilo on May 30, 2017.

There is no specified timeframe set for Judge Amano to make her ruling on the case, but many are expecting a mid-late summer or early fall decision.

More: Hawaii Tribune-Herald

Follow Astronomy Hawaii on Facebook and Instagram.